Spread among the hills in Serta County in Kardze, eastern Tibet, Larung Gar Buddhist Institute is the largest and one of the most significant sites in Tibetan Buddhism. It was established in 1980 and has grown over the years to become home to anywhere between 10,000 and 40,000 residents. These residents include monks, nuns and visiting students, who come from Tibet, China and other countries to learn.
In June 2016, the government of Serta County issued an order stating that the number of residents at Larung Gar had to be reduced to 5,000 people by October 2017. The order came from the very top – the Chinese central government in Beijing.
The order also decreed that vacated residences were to be demolished, along with other buildings such as nuns’ hostels and old people’s homes.
It also effectively put Larung Gar’s internal affairs under the control of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). It handed majority control of Larung Gar’s management to the CCP and stipulated that Larung Gar’s financial management should be handed over to Chinese authorities.
Official sources stated that the order was issued for the residents’ safety, to ease overcrowding and to reduce the risk of fire. But the residents of Larung Gar were never consulted and their wishes to remain at the monastery and practice their faith in peace were ignored.
"According to the latest figures, 4,828 people have been evicted and at least 4,725 buildings destroyed"
Demolitions, forced removals and their consequences
The demolitions began a month later, in July 2016. They were carried out by Chinese work teams consisting of workers, local government officials, police and security services, accompanied by digging teams. The demolitions and removals took place throughout the rest of the year until December, when there was a pause due to the winter conditions. According to the latest figures, 4,828 people have been evicted and at least 4,725 buildings destroyed.
The demolitions have had a devastating effect on people across Tibet, as well as the residents themselves. One resident likened the demolitions to “destroying heaven”. Three nuns are reported to have taken their own lives in protest against this destruction. One of them, Rinzin Dolma, committed suicide on 20 July 2016 and left a note saying she could not “bear the pain of the endless Chinese harassment of innocent Buddhists who quietly studied at the institute”.
Those removed from Larung Gar were returned to their native regions of Tibet, often miles away from their colleagues and friends at Larung Gar. Due to the travel restrictions imposed in the Tibetan Autonomous Region, it is highly unlikely that residents will be able to meet again. This was reflected in video footage of the removals that was smuggled out of Larung Gar and which shows residents crying as those being removed are put on coaches and driven out of the site. Residents who have been removed from the site have been made to sign pledges promising not to return to live there.
Monks and nuns who have been returned to their native regions from Larung Gar have been prevented from joining new monasteries and nunneries. Some have been subjected to humiliating patriotic re-education sessions, in which they are required to sing Chinese propaganda songs and denounce their own Tibetan culture and religion.
The demolitions have had a devastating effect on people across Tibet, as well as the residents themselves. One resident likened the demolitions to “destroying heaven”.
MPs, representatives and government bodies around the world have condemned the evictions and demolitions at Larung Gar:
The co-chairs of the United States’ Human Rights Commission wrote to the Chinese Ambassador to the United States in October 2016, expressing their "deep concern" over the removals and demolitions and urging China to “stop the demolitions and evictions, rebuild and restore the affected infrastructure, and permit all those people under Chinese jurisdiction who wish to pursue their Buddhist faith to do so without government interference or ‘guidance.”
The European Parliament, the legislative body of the European Union, passed a strong resolution in December 2016, demanding that China halt the demolitions and forced removals at Larung Gar, and respect Tibetans’ religious freedoms.
There has, as yet, been little condemnation from senior government ministers and leaders. Pressure from these sources would draw international attention to the evictions and demolitions and put pressure on the Chinese government to halt the destruction. Such pressure would also honour past statements from international governments, including the UK, that they are concerned with the protection of the right to religious freedom in Tibet.
In late 2016 we put together the following short film (ten minutes) to explain the situation at Larung Gar. Please watch and share it if you can.
Holding China to account
China wouldn't allow any external groups in to monitor what was happening at Larung Gar. So, in 2017, we commissioned satellites to fly over the site and take high definition photos of what was happening there. Thanks to these images, we have clear proof which shows large areas, once containing dwellings, that have now been completely cleared.
We also received images and testimony from a reporter who was able to sneak on-site to take photos and speak with residents. He was able to gather evidence that China was planning to build infrastructure for vast numbers of visitors - it looks like Larung Gar may be made into a tourist site.
For further information on China's campaign of destruction at Larung Gar, see our "Destroying Heaven" report from October 2017 (pdf).
Freedom of Religion in Tibet
The evictions and demolitions at Larung Gar are part of a wider attack on freedom of religion in Tibet. Despite the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) being officially atheist, the government attempts to exert control over Tibetan Buddhism, a religion that unifies many Tibetans. The CCP sees its control over Tibetan Buddhism as a means of ending the resistance to its military occupation of Tibet. In April 2016, Chinese president Xi Jinping stated: “Religious groups… must adhere to the leadership of the Communist Party of China.”
The US State Department's 2016 report on international religious freedom describes the repression of religious freedom in Tibet as “severe”. It records “reports of extrajudicial killings, prolonged detention without trial, torture, and arrests of individuals due to their religious practices”.
Tibetan monasteries and nunneries have increasingly been put under the control of the CCP. They are required to fly Chinese flags and many are run from inside by committees loyal to Beijing. CCTV cameras are often installed. Numbers of residents at each monastery are tightly regulated. Chinese regulations also forbid Tibetans from establishing new monasteries. Tibetans are intimidated by security forces at prayer festivals and denied the opportunity to travel for religious teachings.